Common Renters Insurance Scams and Ways to Protect Yourself

Photo of author
Written By Adeyemi Adetilewa

Renters’ insurance scams are unfortunately becoming more common as scammers become more sophisticated in their methods. If you are a renter, it is important to know what to watch out for so you can protect yourself from being scammed.

What is renters insurance?

First, let’s review what renters insurance is. Renters insurance is a type of insurance policy that covers your personal belongings in case they are stolen, damaged, or destroyed. It can also provide liability coverage in case someone is injured in your home and you are found to be responsible.

Renters’ insurance is usually affordable, with premiums typically ranging from $10 to $25 per month. This makes it a smart investment for anyone who rents a home.

Unfortunately, scammers have found ways to exploit renters who may be looking for cheap insurance. These renters’ insurance scams can take many forms, so it is important to be aware of the most common tactics.

What is renters insurance?

What Are Renters Insurance Scams?

Renters insurance scams are fraudulent schemes designed to trick renters into buying fake insurance policies or paying for unnecessary coverage. Scammers typically use a variety of tactics to lure renters into their traps, such as cold-calling, phishing emails, and fake websites that look like legitimate insurance providers.

One common renter’s insurance scam involves selling fake policies to tenants who have just moved into a new apartment. Scammers will pose as insurance agents or representatives and offer renters policies at very low rates.

They will typically ask for payment upfront and promise to send the policy documents later. However, once the payment is made, the scammers disappear, leaving the renter with a worthless piece of paper.

Another type of renters insurance scam involves phishing emails that look like they are from legitimate insurance providers. The emails will often ask for personal information, such as a Social Security number or credit card details, and claim that the renter needs to provide this information to activate their policy. In reality, the scammers are using this information to steal the renter’s identity and commit fraud.

Renters insurance scams are unfortunately all too common, and many renters have fallen victim to these fraudulent schemes. One recent example is a scam that was uncovered in California, where a group of fraudsters posed as insurance agents and sold fake renters insurance policies to hundreds of tenants. The scam was only discovered when renters tried to file claims and found out that their policies were invalid.

In another example, a group of scammers in Florida set up fake insurance websites that looked like legitimate providers. They offered renters policies at very low rates, and many tenants fell for the scam. However, when they tried to file claims, they discovered that their policies were worthless, and the insurance scammers were nowhere to be found.

Common renters insurance scams

Common renters insurance scams

Here are some of the common renters’ insurance scams to protect yourself from today:

1. Fake insurance websites

One of the common renters’ insurance scams is for scammers to create fake insurance websites that mimic legitimate insurance companies. These websites may offer renters insurance at prices that seem too good to be true, and they may even use the names and logos of real insurance companies to make themselves seem more legitimate.

Once a renter purchases insurance from one of these fake websites, they may find that their policy is invalid or that the company is non-existent. The scammer will have taken their money and disappeared.

Example: An insurance scammer created a fake insurance website that used the name and logo of a popular renters insurance company. The website offered renters insurance at prices that were significantly lower than what the popular insurance company actually charged.

However, the policies sold on the website were not valid, and the popular insurance company had no connection to the fake insurance website.

2. Phishing scams

Phishing scams are when insurance scammers send emails or text messages that appear to be from legitimate companies but are actually designed to steal personal information. These messages may contain links to fake websites or ask the recipient to provide sensitive information like social security numbers or credit card numbers.

Insurance scammers may use phishing scams to target renters who are looking for insurance quotes or who have recently purchased a policy. They may send emails that appear to be from an insurance company, asking the renter to provide additional information to complete their policy.

Example: Scammers targeted renters in New York City with a phishing scam that used the name and logo of Lemonade, a real insurance company.

The scam email asked recipients to verify their policy information by clicking a link, which took them to a fake Lemonade website where they were asked to provide personal information.

3. Door-to-door scams

Some insurance scammers will go door-to-door, pretending to be insurance agents who are selling renters insurance. They may use high-pressure sales tactics to convince renters to purchase policies on the spot, often without providing any documentation or proof of coverage.

Once the renter has paid for the policy, they may find that it is not valid or that the “agent” has disappeared with their money.

Example: A man in Texas was arrested for posing as an insurance agent and selling fake renters insurance policies to residents in his area. The man would go door-to-door, claiming to be a representative of a legitimate insurance company, and convince renters to purchase policies from him.

However, the insurance policies were not valid, and the man had no affiliation with the insurance company he claimed to represent.

How to protect yourself from renters insurance scams

How to protect yourself from renters insurance scams

The good news is that there are several ways to avoid falling victim to renters insurance scams. Here are some tips to keep in mind:

1. Do your research

Before purchasing renters insurance, make sure you research the company and the policy thoroughly. Check their credentials, read online reviews, and look for any red flags that might indicate a scam.

Look for reviews from other renters, and check to make sure the company is licensed to sell insurance in your state.

2. Verify the company

If you receive an email or text message from an insurance company, make sure to verify that it is legitimate before providing any personal information. You can do this by calling the company directly or visiting their website (not through a link provided in the message).

3. Be wary of door-to-door salespeople

If someone comes to your door claiming to be an insurance agent, ask for identification and documentation to prove that they are who they say they are. If they can’t provide this, or if you are not sure, don’t purchase anything from them.

4. Don’t fall for prices that seem too good to be true

If an insurance policy is being offered at a price that seems too good to be true, it probably is. Make sure to compare prices from multiple insurance companies to get a sense of what the average cost is.

5. Use a trusted insurance broker

Working with a trusted insurance broker can help you avoid renters insurance scams by connecting you with reputable insurance companies and policies. Insurance brokers have a duty to act in their client’s best interests and can help them navigate the complex world of insurance.

6. Don’t trust cold calls or unsolicited emails

If you receive a cold-call or unsolicited email from an insurance provider, be wary. Legitimate providers typically don’t use these tactics to sell policies.

7. Verify the policy documents

Always verify the policy documents before you pay for renters insurance. Make sure the policy covers the things you want to protect, and check that the insurance provider is licensed in your state.

8. Use secure websites

If you are buying renters insurance online, make sure the website is secure. Look for the padlock icon in the browser address bar and make sure the URL starts with HTTPS.

9. Protect your personal information

Never give out personal information, such as your Social Security number or credit card details, to anyone you don’t trust, either online or offline. If you are unsure, contact the insurance provider directly and ask for clarification.

Protect your personal information


Renters’ insurance scams are a serious problem that can cause financial hardship and emotional distress for unsuspecting tenants.

Renters insurance scams are a real threat, but with a little knowledge and awareness, you can protect yourself from being scammed. Remember to do your research, verify the company or individual you are working with and don’t fall for prices that seem too good to be true.

By staying vigilant, you can protect yourself from these fraudulent schemes and enjoy the peace of mind that comes with knowing your belongings are covered. Remember, if a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is.

Disclaimer. The views and opinions expressed here are those of the authors. They do not purport to reflect the opinions or views of Any content provided by our bloggers or authors is of their opinion and is not intended to malign any organization, company, individual, or anyone or anything.

For questions, inquiries and advert placements on the blog, please send an email to the Editor at ideasplusbusiness[at]gmail[dot]com. You can also follow on Twitter here and like our page on Facebook here. This website contains affiliate links to some products and services. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links at no extra cost to you.